Is it possible to make a .NET application always an admin while being run on a user account without a UAC popup? I've spent some time searching for this capability but haven't found any satisfactory answers.
For some background info, users are running a test application in a manufacturing environment where a dongle is plugged into a USB(to serial) port. Sometimes windows messes up the COM port and cycling the port can resolve the issue. We have discovered we can do this programmatically with admin privileges, but we do not want the users to be admins, and we also don't want the users to deal with a UAC popup or, god forbid, click "no" on the UAC popup to disable our capabilities and mess up the entire process.
How do I force my .NET application to run as administrator?
I have found this old thread but their solutions all require the user to be admin or the usual UAC popup.
Is there something we can do to enable this capability or are we forever chained to the UAC prompt? We do own these machines and control the applications and users running on them.
EDIT: We are cycling the COM port using this method:
string ComPortName { get; set; } = "USB Serial Port (COM12)";
private void button1_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
SelectQuery query = new SelectQuery("Win32_PnPEntity", "Name=" + '"' + ComPortName + '"');
ManagementObjectSearcher myDevices = new ManagementObjectSearcher(query);
foreach (ManagementObject item in myDevices.Get())
{
textBox1.AppendText("Disabling port " + ComPortName + Environment.NewLine);
ManagementBaseObject inParams = item.InvokeMethod("Disable", null, null);
Thread.Sleep(3000);
textBox1.AppendText("Enabling port " + ComPortName + Environment.NewLine);
ManagementBaseObject UWFEnable = item.InvokeMethod("Enable", null, null);
Thread.Sleep(3000);
textBox1.AppendText("Finished cycling port " + ComPortName);
}
}
You can't, not without at least an UAC prompt. This is totally unavoidable, otherwise Windows wouldn't have any security if it was possible - it MUST be totally impossible, not just "difficult", to bypass UAC.
Some clues to solve anyway your problem:
You can force your application to always ask for elevation (i.e. make it to require administrative privileges) since the first step. Dangerous, but at least, you won't mess the whole software chain: it would be elevated from start.
You can ask for UAC only when it's really needed (for example, when launching a particular sub-process, or launching your own application in elevated mode while keeping context). Obviously, you'll ask again and again until the elevated subprocess is created: if user click on "No", then you try again to launch it. Annoying, but again, you won't mess up the whole process.
You can write a Windows service, that will run under administrative privileges, to perform the COM cycle task you need. Then, you can invoke this service from non-elevated user space, without requiring any elevation. I would recommend this solution.
No, you cannot.
Imagine the user is a standard user - e.g. a 5 year old daughter
She cannot just become an administrator.
If anyone could just become an administrator - then there's no point in having security. And Windows NT is a secure operating system.
Solution to your problem
The easiest way to solve your problem is to grant Everyone permission to do the thing. Because in order to do it: someone needs permission.
We have discovered we can do this programmatically with admin privileges
You don't mention what actions you are taking programmatically, or what Windows API you're calling.
If it involves a registry key, or file, or service
Grant Modify permission
to the Users group (or the Everyone group if you prefer)
This way the user's then have permission to do these things.
There's no shame in granting your users permissions to do the thing - it's what you want them to do. They should have permissions to do it.
If you care about defense-in-depth, you could follow the priciple of least privilege, and rather than granting everyone permission to do the thing, you can grant it to one user:
the user that a service runs as
the user that a scheduled task runs as
And then you only need to worry about your program communicating with a service (asking it to do the thing), or trigger the scheduled task (so that it can do the thing).
This way it's only the service/task that has permissions - and you grant that service/task the Modify permission on the thing that your standard users are currently denied from.
Imagine Windows XP
Imagine how you would have solved this before UAC:
the user is a standard user
and there is no UAC convenience feature to help them elevate to an administrator
In that case you would have to do one of the above:
grant everyone permission to the registry key, or folder
create a service or scheduled task that does have permission: and have your program ask them to do it
Related
my installer run as administrator, but on complete i want the exe to run as current user.
i am using nsis and already tried UAC
!insertmacro UAC_AsUser_ExecShell "" "some.exe" "" "" ""
but still it run as administrator.
tried to use task scheduler
string path = System.Reflection.Assembly.GetExecutingAssembly().Location;
td.Actions.Add(new ExecAction("" + path + "", "", null));
td.Settings.DisallowStartIfOnBatteries = false;
td.Settings.AllowHardTerminate = false;
td.Settings.StopIfGoingOnBatteries = false;
td.Settings.ExecutionTimeLimit = System.TimeSpan.Zero;
td.Settings.IdleSettings.StopOnIdleEnd = false;
// Register the task in the root folder
ts.RootFolder.RegisterTaskDefinition("task", td);
but the task also goto administrator and i cant get it to current user.
any ideas ?
My personal recommendation is that you just remove the option to run your application at the end of your installer. The user can just start it from the start menu, it should be highlighted as new and everything.
As you probably know, UAC really changed how common it is for applications to run as a different user than the "logged in" user. You just have to deal with the fact that UAC exists and decide if you feel it is worth the amount of time required to work around it and possible bugs and issues that might arise.
There are at least 4 ways to run something as the "current user", all of them have issues and can fail or end up running as the "wrong" non-admin user:
Use the token of the (hopefully) non-elevated parent, this is what the NSIS UAC plugin does.
Use the Windows Task Scheduler. This was a recommended practice in the early Vista days but I believe Microsoft has moved away from this method.
Use a shell COM object in the Explorer process that hosts the taskbar to call ShellExecute for you. The StdUtils plugin provides a ExecShellAsUser method that does this.
Use a Windows NT service. Because it runs as SYSTEM it can get the token handle of a user in any session.
If you decide that you still want to attempt to do this then you need to decide on your definition of current user before you choose a method.
Is it the user that logged in on the welcome screen? Is it the user the Explorer shell (Taskbar etc) is running as? Is it the parent process of your setup process? You should also keep in mind that runas.exe exists and a user might try to run something as a particular user for a reason...
I have created a windows application that start\stop windows service
now when i tried to start\stop sq-server engine from my application it throw an exception
when i run my Application as administrator it works
now i can run my application as administrator using app.manifest but the problem is that my client does not have permission as administrator
what type of permission my Application need and how to do that?
public static void start()
{
ServiceController sc = new ServiceController(ServiceName, ServerName);
sc.Start();
sc.WaitForStatus(System.ServiceProcess.ServiceControllerStatus.Running);
}
public static void stop()
{
ServiceController sc = new ServiceController(ServiceName, ServerName);
sc.Stop();
sc.WaitForStatus(System.ServiceProcess.ServiceControllerStatus.Stopped);
}
Your app is limited to the permissions of the person running it. If they don't have rights to do something, then neither will your application. You say that your client is not an administrator, so in order for your app to work for them an administrator will have to grant their login the permissions needed to start/stop services.
One of the following needs to happen:
The user needs to get admin rights
An admin needs to assign the user permissions to start/stop
services
Your program will need to be run under alternate credentials
For the 3rd option, this can be done at least a couple different ways:
Shift-right-click an application and it will give you a menu
option to run as another user. This option requires someone to be
there to enter their credentials every time you run the application
this way.
Add the ability for someone to enter their credentials into your
application and then impersonate them in your application when
starting/stopping services. This method would allow you to give
them the option to save their credentials for future use (not saying
that's a good idea though).
When a user saves a file from my application, they currently can't save to restricted locations (like C:). I think this is a good restriction, but I would like to provide a UAC prompt to elevate privileges and allow a user to save in a restricted area.
I've seen lots of answers around this topic that involve spawning a new process with elevated privileges using 'runas'. Also, it seems like this can be done by impersonating another user. From what I understand, both of those methods require a user to provide user credentials.
What I'm wanting to do is basically what Windows itself does. When you try to copy a file to C:\ in Windows 7 (assuming you've got UAC set to its default level), you get the following prompt:
Once you click the Continue button with the UAC shield, the file is copied to C:\ with no prompt for credentials (assuming you're logged on with admin privileges).
How can I replicate this behavior in my application for admin users? They shouldn't have to impersonate any other user because they already have admin privileges. Can anyone provide details on what Windows is doing during this process? Are they spawning a new explorer.exe process with elevated privileges?
You need to do what Windows does. And spawn a new process which will run with elevated rights. There are no shortcuts here. The token that is allocated when a process starts is what determines what rights the process has. That token cannot be changed after the process has started. If you need to elevate, you need a new process.
I've seen lots of answers around this topic that involve spawning a new process with elevated privileges using 'runas'. Also, it seems like this can be done by impersonating another user. From what I understand, both of those methods require a user to provide user credentials.
No that's not the case. If the current user is not an admin, then the UAC dialog will prompt for new credentials of a user that does have admin rights. That's the over-the-shoulder UAC dialog. On the other hand, if the current user is an admin then they just get the consent dialog. That's the dialog that's shown on the secure desktop and just asks for you to click Continue.
The one thing that Windows components can do that you cannot is start a process elevated without showing you the consent dialog. That happens on Windows 7 only (not on Vista), and only if you have the UAC setting at the new Default setting that was added in Windows 7. That's how Explorer is able to show the dialog that you included in the question and then start an elevated process to do the copying without showing the consent UAC dialog. Only Windows components are granted that ability.
But the bottom line is that you need to start a new process that runs elevated. Using the runas verb is the canonical way to do it.
Programming Elevated Privilege/UAC
Running applications with more privileges than required is against the
principle of least privilege, and may have potential security
vulnerability. To defend this, Windows Vista introduces User Account
Control (UAC), to protect operating system by running applications
with reduced privileges (as a normal user), even the current user is
signed in as an administrator. More and more XP/2K users are also use
normal user account for daily use. Read UAC Demystified first to fully
understand UAC.
There are two common mistakes that developers tend to make:
Request the end-user to run an application with administrator privilege even
though this is not necessary, most of the time because of bad design
practices. These applications either scare away end-users, or
potentially have security vulnerability.
Do not request the end-user
to run the application elevated but try to perform operations that
require administrator privilege. These applications simply break under
Windows Vista or Windows XP/2K normal user account.
The downloadable sample code demonstrates how to programming elevated
privilege/UAC. Both WPF and Windows Forms sample applications are
provided. Run the application for the following scenarios to see the
difference:
Normal user, Windows XP/Windows Vista: the UAC shield icon
is displayed. Clicking “Save to C:\” displays “Run As” dialog, asking
user to enter administrator password to continue;
Administrator, Windows XP/Windows Vista with UAC disabled: the UAC shield icon is
hidden. Clicking “Save to C:\” completed without any dialog;
Administrator, Windows Vista with UAC enabled: the UAC shield icon is
displayed. Clicking “Save to C:\” displays dialog asking user’s
permission to continue.
Link to Download
Calling the elevated execute (testing for admin first):
private void SaveToRootFolder_Click(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
string fileName = #"C:\Test.txt";
if (App.IsAdmin)
DoSaveFile(textBox1.Text, textBox2.Text, fileName);
else
{
NameValueCollection parameters = new NameValueCollection();
parameters.Add("Text1", textBox1.Text);
parameters.Add("Text2", textBox2.Text);
parameters.Add("FileName", fileName);
string result = Program.ElevatedExecute(parameters);
if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(result))
MessageBox.Show(result);
}
}
Elevated Executes:
internal static string ElevatedExecute(NameValueCollection parameters)
{
string tempFile = Path.GetTempFileName();
File.WriteAllText(tempFile, ConstructQueryString(parameters));
try
{
ProcessStartInfo startInfo = new ProcessStartInfo();
startInfo.UseShellExecute = true;
startInfo.WorkingDirectory = Environment.CurrentDirectory;
Uri uri = new Uri(Assembly.GetExecutingAssembly().GetName().CodeBase);
startInfo.FileName = uri.LocalPath;
startInfo.Arguments = "\"" + tempFile + "\"";
startInfo.Verb = "runas";
Process p = Process.Start(startInfo);
p.WaitForExit();
return File.ReadAllText(tempFile);
}
catch (Win32Exception exception)
{
return exception.Message;
}
finally
{
File.Delete(tempFile);
}
}
A limited option, useful only when Moving, Renaming, Copying, and Deleting files:
SHFileOperation
If you attempt to perform a file operation via this function, Windows will provide the elevation prompt to the user.
Note there are some drawbacks for this:
This only works for Moving, Renaming, Copying, and Deleting. Saving a new file this way would require saving to a temp directory, then Moving it to the desired location. This does not solve the problem of the Save File Dialog not allowing you to select a UAC protected location as a target.
If the target directory doesn't exist (for a Move or Copy), SHFileOperation can prompt the user if the target directory should be created. However, it will NOT ask for elevated privileges to do so, and so will fail under a UAC protected location. The workaround for this is to manually create the non-existent directories in a temporary location, then Move/Copy them to the target location. This WILL provide the UAC prompt.
You need to have contingency plans in place for if the user selects 'Skip' or 'Cancel' to the Move/Copy dialog, or if the user selects 'No' at the UAC prompt.
Our setup has an embedded manifest that triggers the UAC before the application starts. (The applications runs as an admin user). However, if the setup needs to install the .NET Framework, we have to continue the setup after a reboot. For this reason, we have to create a registry key in the current user's RunOnce.
Unfortunatly, HKEY_CURRENT_USER points to the Administrator's registry. We need to find out the user that is currently logged in and started the installation. (Th normal USER clicked the setup.exe, an ADMIN entered his details in the UAC prompt. We need to find out who the USER was)
I've tried all the usual methods (Environment.UserName, WindowsIdentity.GetCurrent())
Thanks!
You can use the LsaEnumerateLogonSessions function to retreive what you need. However, it is a winapi C function call. If you need a managed version of it, I belive you can look at the source code for Cassia, which uses this function in its terminal services API. The call should be the same. You can also look here.
Also you can use the NetWkstaUserEnum WINAPI function. You can find a managed wrapper for it here
With Cassia library this code works fine:
ITerminalServicesManager manager = new TerminalServicesManager();
ITerminalServicesSession session = manager.CurrentSession;
string userInfo = session.DomainName + "\\" + session.UserName;
NTAccount account = session.UserAccount;
Run your initial setup.exe as a small executable that puts up a splash screen while invoking your real setup program as a child process. The small EXE is not run as admin and can pass the logged in user name to the child process. The child process invokes UAC and runs in the admin context but already has the logged in username as a command line parameter.
It is not possible to retrieve the original user if your application is ran as Administrator:
If a user launches Setup by right-clicking its EXE file and selecting
"Run as administrator", then this flag, unfortunately, will have no
effect, because Setup has no opportunity to run any code with the
original user credentials. The same is true if Setup is launched from
an already-elevated process. Note, however, that this is not an Inno
Setup-specific limitation; Windows Installer-based installers cannot
return to the original user credentials either in such cases.
Source : InnoSetup Help
As said by Matthew in comments, you should not run your application as Administrator but only trigger UAC when needed in your code.
This returns the name of the logged in Windows User by stripping out the domain:
using System.Security.Principal; // here is the security namespace you need
...
string userName = WindowsIdentity.GetCurrent().Name.Replace("\\", "|");
string[] split = userName.Split(new Char[] { '|' });
lblDebug.Text = (split.Count() > 1) ? split[1] : userName;
I have got a project that can copy files to another client's desktops in my domain.There is 300+ client machine.But there is a problem.When i run this project in a non admin user account in my domain.It cant copy files getting error about Access Denied , user restrictions.I wanna do this program like this , in non admin user account when user start to copy files ;
first my program will get admin access by loggin in my admin user accoun to domain than will copy files.Than logout.How can i do this ? I wanna do this with C#.
I had a similar problem: Production needed to run one of my programs that processes files on a location on the network where they don't have any access.
I ended up using Impersonation, which allowed me to run the file processing thread under a set of credentials set at runtime by my program.
In AD I created a special user account with all required permissions for exclusive use by this program.
I know it’s not at all secure, but it works and the odds that it would even occur to someone to hack my program to get these credentials is remote.
Anyway, look into Impersonation I found these resources helpful:
Safely Impersonating Another User
Brian Low's ImpersonationHelper class
-Jay
You can switch privileges when starting the program from itself or from another program. You can do this with two programs, one that runs as the user account and then launches your privileged application. (or launch itself with a different command line to indicate the different run-mode.)
To launch a program in C# as a different user, do this,
// Create a secure version of the password
SecureString pass = new SecureString();
foreach ( char c in _pass.Text )
{
pass.AppendChar( c );
}
Process process = Process.Start( "PrivilegedProgram.exe", _arguments, _user.Text, pass, _domain.Text );
you need to change the thread to the context of an admin user. How you do that in a secure way is the challenge. This sounds like a quick utility program where the security may not be a big deal, however. Just change the admin's password once the utility has been run.