I have code written in ANSI C that I would like to use in C#. I have compiled the C code into a DLL and created C# wrapper classes to interop with the C code. The point of the wrapper is to simplify a users interaction with the underlying C code.
[DllImport(DLL, CharSet = CharSet.Ansi, CallingConvention = CallingConvention.Cdecl)]
private static extern void PrintHelloWorld();
public void PrintHelloWorldC()
{
PrintHelloWorld();
}
Above is a simplified example of what I have done so far. Now, I am trying to create a DLL from the C# wrapper classes I wrote. From here I could give both the DLLs created and someone would be able to interact with the C# based DLL to interact with the underlying C based DLL. Below is what I have done and what problem I am having.
I compile the C code into a DLL in Visual Studio 2019 with my Configuration=Release and Platform=Win32.
I compile my C# classes into a DLL in Visual Studio 2019 with my
Configuration=Release, Platform=Win32, and Platform Target as x86.
I create a new project and link my C# DLL and set Platform Target as x86.
I put my C DLL into the Debug folder of the project so that it is available to the C# DLL through the marshal directive.
I try to make a call into the C# DLL and below are the chain of events occurring.
Program calls C# DLL method PrintHelloWorldC() and is successful
Within PrintHelloWorldC() it tries to make a call to PrintHelloWorld();.
Following Error Occurs:
System.BadImageFormatException
HResult=0x8007000B
Message=An attempt was made to load a program with an incorrect format. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x8007000B)
My research yielded that it was most likely a mismatch in Platform Target between the DLLs and Test Project, however, I have double checked all the configurations and they should all be compiled for x86.
Below is what additional testing I have done.
Created a C# Project, and wrote simple code to make a call directly into the C based DLL. This works fine.
It seems that as soon as I try to use the two DLLs on top of each other in another project I start facing issues.
Any help or guidance is appreciated. Thanks in advance!
Related
I put a dll build in native C++ as a Universal DLL in my project directory of C# UWP app and setting content to copy always it was finding it and then the next day suddenly nothing, constantly getting:
"Unable to load DLL 'AVEngine.dll': The specified module could not be found. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x8007007E)"
I am calling with:
[DllImport(DLLName, CallingConvention = CallingConvention.Cdecl)]
private static extern int OpenForProcessing();
I ensured the architecture and build config matches, I have also checked SDK versions (min/target versions), I'm stumped.
Use Dependency Walker to check dependencies of your AVEngine.dll. Probably some of them missing and because of it Dll cannot be loaded.
Better proper approach to expose old functionality to your modern C# UWP application is to wrap AVEngine.dll logic using a WinRT component. Then you can reference this component in UWP application. Article "Use Existing C++ Code in a Universal Windows Platform App" could be helpful.
Update
I have now run through the tutorial 3 times with the same results (Visual Studio/Windows is unable to recognise the DLL as a valid file). This must be an issue with my environment, as mike below ran through the tutorial and it worked fine.
I did notice this in the C++ project's solution explorer on my last run:
Does anyone know if this is okay? There seems to be a lot of Red stop-signs which to me would suggest something bad...
Following this tutorial, I have ended up with the following:
C#
using System.Runtime.InteropServices;
namespace TestImport
{
class Program
{
[DllImport("TestLib.dll")]
public static extern void DisplayHelloFromDLL();
static void Main(string[] args)
{
DisplayHelloFromDLL();
}
}
}
C++
In .cpp file Source Files
#include <stdio.h>
extern "C"
{
__declspec(dllexport) void DisplayHelloFromDLL()
{
printf("Hello from DLL !\n");
}
}
When debugging in Visual Studio:
An unhandled exception of type 'System.DllNotFoundException' occurred in TestImport.exe
Additional information: An attempt was made to load a program with an incorrect format. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x8007000B)
When running the built EXE (from he same folder as the Dll):
An attempt was made to load a program with an incorrect format.
Have I done anything wrong in the above code?
I did do all of this in VS 2015, where the tutorial calls for VS 2010, howeve rI couldn't find a more up-to-date tutorial.
When I try to add the project as a reference by Project -> Add Reference ... I am seeing this error:
A reference to 'Path\To\MyLib.dll' could not be added. Please make sure
that the file is accessible, and that it is a valid assembly or COM
component.
Which makes me think that the issue is either with the source code or the DLLs configuration.
I have also tried building both files and putting them in the same folder before running the Executable, but without any improved results (same error as when running the EXE above).
Solution Explorer Screenshot:
Make sure the name of your C++ project and DllImport parameter are the same. Also, if the dll file is not located in the same directory as your C# project, make sure to add the dll into your Debug/Release folder.
Also! Make sure that you are running in the same 32/64 bit mode when compiling.. if you compiled the dll using 32 bit and try to use it in a 64 bit C# program, it won't work.
OK, now build this application, and then copy the previously built DLL into the Debug/Release directory of the current application. The DLL should be in the same directory as your main application.
Did you do the bolded text? Your C# app won't know where to look for the DLL and it looks in the build folder, by default.
An unhandled exception of type 'System.DllNotFoundException'
It happened to me, because of the imported c++ dll, its own dependency dlls were missing.
After copying them into Debug/Release folder everything worked.
Pretty much all the questions about this problem end up people trying to run 64 bit dll with 32 bit app, or 64 app - 32 dll. I have a diferent problem.
My delphi application is 32 bit, in visual studio i have set the target platform to x86. Using the unmanaged exports for DllExport funcionality.
Whenever i try to import the dll into my delphi application it shows me this error.
In a C# dll it looks like this
[DllExport("Open", CallingConvention = CallingConvention.Cdecl)]
public static void Open() {
MessageBox.Show("hello");
}
Inside delphi it looks like this
procedure Open(); cdecl; external 'mydll.dll';
When i run the app, it shows the error. Then i took another C# dll project made by another person, added a function just like the one i had in my own dll. Added the dll to the delphi app folder, ran the app and it was fine, i could call the Open();
I tried to see if there were any differences between my c# project and the other one and failed to see it. Everything looked similar.
Well, i started wondering what am i doing wrong. And i believe i have found the cause, sort of.
When i created a solution i picked Windows Forms Application (thinking that i need a form, which i will call from a dll later on), then went to properties and changed it to Class library, this was enough to compile it into a dll.
Then i figured i should try a different project type, i picked Class library project type this time. I quickly added same code as i had, compiled, moved dll to delphi app, and was surprised that it actually worked.
So my question is, WHY did it not work when i picked Windows Form Application and changed the type to dll? There was no difference in project files settings as far as i could see.
EDIT 1:
I have also figured a couple more things. The faulty solution (lets call it Solution A), as i said, was created by selecting Windows Forms (this creates a solution + project in one go).
Good solution (Solution B) was created by selecting Class library, again both the solution and project created all together.
If i delete the project from solution A, and add new project by selecting proper one (Class library) it will still compile a non working dll for me.
SO creating new solution (and selecting Class library) from scratch is a must for the dll to work.
Second thing i noticed were the difference in files that were generated once i compile the projects.
In a solution A i was getting a .dll, a .pdb and a RGiesecke.DllExport.Metadata.dll.
In a solution B i was getting a .dll, a .exp, a .lib and .pdb. No dllExport dll this time.
Both are DEBUG configurations.
I have several Unmanaged C++ written lib files which I need to link to Managed C++ dll.
Then I need to invoke functions of this Managed C++ from C# application.
First step is OK - Managed C++ dll is created, I can see with ildasm that it exports functions I need. However when I try to call this function from my C#-written test app it says:
An unhandled exception of type 'System.IO.FileLoadException' occurred in Unknown Module.
A procedure imported by {MyManagedCPP.dll} could not be loaded.
This message goes from VS2010.
I made simple experiment - removed dependencies from all lib files in Managed C++ dll and rebuild it.
With this change it is OK - app starts, I can call functions of Managed C++ dll from C# test app.
Is it not possible by design to call managed c++ functions when dll has static linkage with lib files? Technical restriction? Or there is some workaround?
Thanks
You no doubt have an implicit dependency on a native DLL. It isn't clear from the question what DLL that might be. It could be msvcrxx.dll for example, a runtime support library for native C++ code. Which would be rather bad, you don't want to mix CRT versions. Such a missing DLL otherwise prevents the C++/CLI assembly from getting loaded, producing the FileLoadException.
If you have no idea what that DLL might be then you could use SysInternals' ProcMon utility. The trace will show you the program searching for the DLL and not finding it. If it is msvcrxx.dll then be sure to rebuild the .lib files using the same compiler version you used to build the C++/CLI assembly. If it is something else then make sure you copy that DLL to the build directory.
In my project I have an unmanaged native C++ dll and a C# application. I am trying to import a function from the unmanaged dll using DllImport but I keep getting a DllNotFoundException.
Here is my code that calls the DLL.
using System.Runtime.InteropServices;
namespace TestApp
{
public delegate void UpdateDelegate(string s);
class Program
{
[DllImport("CGPUnmanagedLibrary.dll")]
internal static extern int parse_raw_gsod_file(
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.LPStr)]
string filePath,
int minTemp,
UpdateDelegate callBack);
static void Main(string[] args)
{
UpdateDelegate myCallBack = new UpdateDelegate(Program.Report);
string path = #"C:\Creative Solutions\Projects\Clyde's Garden Planner\Frost Data Database\GSOD Data\GSOD_RAW_DATA\1992\gsod_1992.txt";
int result = parse_raw_gsod_file(path, 32, myCallBack);
Console.Write("Parse completed with exit code: " + result.ToString());
Console.ReadLine();
} // end main function
public static void Report(string msg)
{
Console.Write("Message is ");
Console.WriteLine(msg);
}
} // End class
} // end namespace
I tried copying the DLL to the app output directory but it still can't find it. I also tried adding the DLL project as a reference but I get a popup window saying it can't be added. How do you properly link an unmanged DLL to a managed application?
Update - Here is the full error:
Unable to load DLL 'CGPUnmanagedLibrary': The specified module could not be found. (Exception from HRESULT: 0x8007007E)
Update 2 - I know for sure that the DLL is in the same directory as the .exe trying to load it. This makes me think there is a dependency in the DLL that isn't getting loaded. I'm only using basic C++ libraries in the DLL (string, math, iostream, etc). Any ideas what could not be loading and why?
Update 3 - Tested with Dependency Walker
Loading my unmanaged C++ DLL in dependency walker showed no errors. I also tried to open my executable in dependency walker and it showed errors loading two DLLs: GPSVC.DLL and IESHIMS.DLL - doesn't make any sense because I am only using standard c++ libraries in my code. I think it may have something to do with the fact that I have a managed C++/CLI DLL trying to load the unmanaged DLL as well (I was trying to implement some C++/CLI wrappers). Anyway, I have since started a new VS solution and moved on. See my answer.
In all likelihood the problem isn't the DLL you're trying to load but one of its (chained) dependencies. Run depends.exe or a similar utility on the DLL to see if all the dependencies can be found. The misleading message "The specified module could not be found" has become a classic annoyance (if not FAQ material!): it leads you to think that your DLL is not being found when almost all of the time it's one of its dependencies that's not being found.
To test, the *.dll needs to be in the same directory as the .exe that is trying to load it. Don't trust Visual Studio to do it for you at this point. Physically copy the file to C:******\Debug\x86\bin\ or whichever configuration you are running under. If in doubt, copy it to all of your bin folders. After you figure out the path, then you start finding ways to automate the project build to copy the file correctly. If that doesn't do it, put it in system32--it will certainly find it there. However, if after doing these things, you still can't find it. There is probably a dependency to your unmanaged dll that is also missing.
First I want to thank everyone for their help. Unfortunately I never did solve this issue (see edits in my main question). The answer turned out to be starting a totally new Visual Studio solution and creating two new projects: C# app and C++ dll. I did away with the need for wrappers as I am now just marshaling two main functions.
Thanks again.
The anwer of user arayq2 made much sense and I was quickly able to solve my problem also.
The dll that couldn't be loaded (DllNotFoundException) in my case is depending upon another dll. This dll (that is not part of my project) was actually compiled with newer versions of certain .h and .lib files. Older versions of these .h and .lib files (with the same filename) were part of the project that compiled the dll that couldn't be loaded.
After I updated my dll project with the newer versions of these .h and .lib files and recompiling my dll project, my problem was solved.
Thank you arayq2!