Develop Reference

Create a Windows service without the use of a timer [duplicate]

I made a Window service and let it work automatically and under localsystem account, when the service starts it fires this message for me and then stops
The [service name] service on local computer started and then stopped. Some Services stop automatically if they are not in use by another services or programs.
What's the problem and what's the solution?

Either you are not starting any threads on the OnStart method to do work, or there is an exception raised within your OnStart method.
If an exception is thrown, it will appear in the Windows Event log. The Windows Event log is a good place to start in any case.
Generally an OnStart method looks like this:
Thread _thread;
protected override void OnStart(string[] args)
{
// Comment in to debug
// Debugger.Break()
// Do initial setup and initialization
Setup();
// Kick off a thread to do work
_thread = new Thread(new MyClass().MyMethod)
_thread.Start();
// Exit this method to indicate the service has started
}

This particular error message means what it says - that your service has started but then quite soon it exited for some reason. The good news is that your service is actually doing something, so you have the executable configured and running as a service properly.
Once started, for some reason it is quitting. You need to find out why this is. Add some debugging to tell you its up and running and known exit cases. If that doesn't reveal the problem then add some debugging to let you know it's still running and work backwards from when that stops.

Are you tracing out any debug information? Most likely an exception is being thrown during your initialization. I would trace out all your exceptions and use Debugview to view them.

I had a similar problem that occurred because my Event Logs were full and the service was unable to write to them. As such, it was impossible to debug by looking for messages in the Event Viewer. I put a try/catch and dumped the exception out to a file. I had to change the settings on my logs to fill as needed instead of every 7 days and this allowed the services to start.
Of course, the root of the problem for me is that I have a nVidia driver issue that is flooding my event logs and now I'm probably beating on the disk, but that's another issue.

Maybe you need to run the service as Local System Account. See this post by Srinivas Ganaparthi.

I had the same issue starting JBoss, then I changed the JAVA_HOME variable, it worked for me. It was the JBoss version that doesn't support the 1.6, it supports 1.5.

I had similar problem and it turned out in my case that the program simply crashed in OnStart method. It tried to read some file that it couldn't find but I suppose that any other program crash would give the same result. In case of Windows forms application you would get some error message but here it was just "your service started and stopped"
If you ever need, like me to read some files from the directory where Windows Service .exe is located, check this topic:
Getting full path for Windows Service

In my case, a method in my service, was being called recursively (as no terminate condition being true) and after specific time my service was being stopped.

Application_start not working

I have written some code in the application_start() method in my global.asax file. It does not get called when I deploy my application on IIS server. The code is accessible when I run it in the .NET framework.
I've tried to restart the application many times, but it's still not working.
I've also tried the suggestion from the following link.
Application_Start not firing?

There are few things you need to know before you are trying to debug Appplication_Start. There are -
One : When the code executes and why it is almost impossible to debug by attaching to it.
The application start method is executed when the application pool starts and your website is being started up for the first time. If you deploy new deliverables to IIS, then IIS might restart it itself, but there is no guarantee that it will. So, deploying new codes does not guarantee that it will restart the pool and he execution of application start. You should restart your application pool to guarantee execution of application start.
While debugging IIS applications, Visual Studio attaches itself to a process something named w3wp.exe or similart (I forgot the actual executable name), which is the worker process and only available after, remember after, your application pool is up and your site is up. So, in other words, if you are seeing this in service list, then the application start has already been executed and attaching to it will not give you a chance to debug it. It is kind of a tug of war with time.
So, in other words, it is kind of impossible to debug application start unless you are very very quick.
Two, the solution 1 - With Dev Server
Launch your application in visual studio with Asp.net development server or IIS express, then you will be able to debug. But if you really want to debug on IIS, then check the next section
Two, the solution 2 - With IIS
There is a library in the name System.Diagnostics, Debuggerand it has a nice way to call debugger in code. You can read it here - http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.diagnostics.debugger.break(v=vs.110).aspx
Modify you application start with this -
public void Application_Start(){
....... //other codes
Debugger.Break() or Debugger.Launch()
}
When this line executes, IIS will halt execution, and will show you a debugger selector window (similar to the one attached), keep your solution open in vs and select that vs from the list, will be able to debug as usual... :)
In case you are using windows 8 and the debugger does not launch, read this article to enable it -
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/mapo/archive/2013/11/07/debugger-launch-not-displaying-jit-debugger-selection-popup-on-windows-8-8-1.aspx
Three: A very important thing
I noticed that you said, you are adding db entries in Application_Start. You should keep in mind that, Application_Start does not have a HttpContext, ViewContext, So your db access code may fail for so many others reasons.

Make sure that the Global.asax file is actually deployed to the destination folder in the root. If the file is not present then the code behind you have written for Application_Start will never be called.
Also make sure the signature is correct
public class Global : System.Web.HttpApplication {
protected void Application_Start(object sender, EventArgs e) {/*do something here like logging so you know it was called*/}
}

If you are running Server 2008R2 (or earlier) and/or IIS 7.5, you might want to look into the Application Initialization module. This can be downloaded here:
www.iis.net/downloads/microsoft/application-initialization
With IIS versions prior to 8.0, the application start is not called until the first web request arrives. I'm reading your question as you want your application start to be fired before the first web request, yes?
Here is a fantastic guide to configuring this module (if it applies to you):
https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/benjaminperkins/2014/01/07/configure-the-iis-application-initialization-module/
The key takeaways is that you need to set your app pool to 'AlwaysRunning' instead of 'OnDemand'. You also need to set a preloadEnabled flag for your website. Once both of these are done, fire off an iisreset and you should see the results of your application start (look in the database since it's writing there).
Other answers are relevant as well, in that this is tough to debug and you're missing all the niceties you're used to such as a httpcontext in app start.
If you are running IIS 8.0 - you should still read the above link to configure preloading.

This did work for me:
Menu -> Build -> Clean Solution
Menu -> Build -> Rebuild Solution
Then, Application_Start() was fired only for the first time.

In my case in production environment App_global.asax.compiled was missing and all content of global.asax not fired.

Windows Service not working when installed, works fine in Debug mode; crashes on Moving/deleting files

I created a windows service which watches a directory. When a file is dumped into it, it takes the data and puts it into a database. Then this file is moved to another directory and deleted. It works fine in debug mode. But when i install it on my computer it stops after throwing the data into the database and the file in question is neither moved or deleted. I suspect a permission issue is involved. I tried to create a event log:
public Service1()
{
InitializeComponent();
if (!System.Diagnostics.EventLog.SourceExists("MySource"))
{
System.Diagnostics.EventLog.CreateEventSource(
"MySource", "MyNewLog");
}
eventLog1.Source = "MySource";
eventLog1.Log = "MyNewLog";
}
So i have three questions.
(1) What could be causing my service to work as described in debug but fail when installed on my computer.(2) I have initiated a event log as shown above. But do i need to add other code to record the event of my service stopping. I presume this would be done in a 'override onShutdown' method.(3) Finally when my service stops, i want to look at the event log. But i do not know how to do this, is in administrative tools? stored as a file on some directory?
Here is edit to this post in lieu of the grateful advice given below.
try
{
File.Move(e.FullPath, finalString);
File.Delete(e.FullPath);
}
catch(Exception q)
{
EventLog.WriteEntry("MySource", q.ToString(), EventLogEntryType.Error);
using (StreamWriter w = new StreamWriter(ConfigurationManager.AppSettings["fmd"], true))
{
w.Write(DateTime.Now.ToString("dd-MM-yyyy_hh-mm-ss"));
w.Write(q.ToString());
}
}
As per suggestion i put a try-catch around the file move and delete plus i added a OnShutdown method:
protected override void OnShutdown()
{
using (StreamWriter w = new StreamWriter(ConfigurationManager.AppSettings["ond"], true))
{
w.Write("stop OnShutdown");
}
//EventLog.WriteEntry("MySource", message, EventLogEntryType.Error);
}
I do not know how to pass any system error message to the shutdown method, so any advice appreciated. When i installed my modified code as a service, it again stopped before moving or deleting the files. Neither of my two logs accessed by a stream recorded anything. Plus the event viewer showed nothing either?

You can write as following,
if (!EventLog.SourceExists("MySource"))
EventLog.CreateEventSource("MySource", "Application");
EventLog.WriteEntry("MySource", message, EventLogEntryType.Error);
to view the event log messages, Goto Administrator Tools -> Event Viewer and look for the source you have created. or Just simply type eventvwr in run window.
When Services installed, it works under SYSTEM User account where service might not have access to some resources. Please put logs and see where exactly the issue is.
If you service installed in your development machine, use attach to process option under DEBUG Menu in Visual Studio to find out.

What could be causing my service to work as described in debug but fail when installed on my computer?
Permissions. The service is likely running under LocalSystem or Network Service if you didn't provide a different identity.
I have initiated a event log as shown above. But do i need to add other code to record the event of my service stopping. I presume this would be done in a 'override onShutdown' method?
Yes, you're assumption is correct.
Finally when my service stops, i want to look at the event log. But i do not know how to do this, is in administrative tools?
Just hit Windows Key+R to get the Run dialog and type eventvwr.

Well i found the reason for all the commotion. I eventually found some logs in the event viewer. They were listed in Administrative events in custom logs. There were three error logs: .Net runtime; Application error & Service Control Manager. In '.Net Runtime' the stack showed a unhandled exception for system.windows.forms. I stupidly included a pop up box in my release version. But even when i commented this away; i got a error. So i went back and found other message boxes, primarily in try catch statements. Removed these and solved the issue.

Windows service can't write to %LOCALAPPDATA%

I have built an app that works only when not run as a Windows service. Well, the service runs, but it doesn't do what it should. The service uses the Local Service account. So to kick off debugging, I thought I'd start with something simple: have it create a directory when it starts:
Directory.CreateDirectory(
Environment.SpecialFolder.LocalApplicationData + "\\MyService");
When I started the service, it stopped almost immediately and Windows reported that fact. When I commented out the above statement, recompiled and re-installed, the service ran without stopping.
Obviously the above line throws an exception of some sort. I have no way of logging the error because I can't write to the file system. Any ideas why Local Service can't create a directory in its own %LOCALAPPDATA%?

You should use GetFolderPath with LocalApplicationData like so:
string folderName = Path.Combine(Environment.GetFolderPath(
Environment.SpecialFolder.LocalApplicationData),
"MyService");
Directory.CreateDirectory(folderName)

I think this might be because there is no special folder. When running as the local service account you are running under that user, not the logged in user. so you are requesting a special folder that probably wont exist, as I don't think the local service has a profile. (I may be wrong) - I was wrong :p
Just in case anyone pops by:
C:\Windows\ServiceProfiles\LocalService
is the local service profile folder, so it will end up in there.
If you want to debug it surround that line with a try catch, and then write the error to a file:
try
{
Directory.CreateDirectory(Environment.SpecialFolder.LocalApplicationData + "\\MyService");
}
catch (Exception ex)
{
System.IO.StreamWriter file = new System.IO.StreamWriter(#"C:\MyServicelog.txt",true);
file.WriteLine(ex.Message);
file.Close();
}
At least then you can see whats causing the error
Martyn

I suggest you write the exception details to the event log. All user accounts have permission to write to the event log as long as the log and source names have already been created by an administrator (which you can do simply by running the app as yourself first).
As to the root cause of the error, it may be because LocalService doesn't normally get a full set of profile folders created by default. I'm not sure whether this is by design, or simply what I have observed on various machines.

Why doesn't System.Threading.Timer callback fire?

I'm not using a Windows Form Timer--I'm using a System.Threading.Timer. No exceptions are raised when instantiating the timer, and to my understanding, System.Threading.Timer's do not need to be explicitly started.
I've tried using a System.Timers.Timer (See comments in code) and changing the signature of the callback with no luck. Inside the callback method, I stubbed in some EventLog writes, and not even the first writes to the event log. All I see in the Event Log is MyService.OnStart fired followed by MyService started (these are both from the OnStart event). Why aren't the timer callback events firing?
public partial class MyService : ServiceBase
{
private static System.Threading.Timer timer;
public MyService()
{
InitializeComponent();
if (!System.Diagnostics.EventLog.SourceExists("MyService"))
{
System.Diagnostics.EventLog.CreateEventSource(
"MyService", "MyServiceLog");
}
eventLog1.Source = "MyService";
eventLog1.Log = "MyServiceLog";
}
protected override void OnStart(string[] args)
{
eventLog1.WriteEntry("MyService.OnStart event fired");
// setup timer to poll and execute an event
//Timer timer = new Timer(new TimerCallback(CheckCalls), null, 0, 10000);
try
{
timer = new System.Threading.Timer(new System.Threading.TimerCallback(CheckCalls), null, 0, 10000);
}
catch (Exception ex)
{
eventLog1.WriteEntry(ex.Message + " Stacktrace: " + ex.StackTrace);
}
eventLog1.WriteEntry("MyServicestarted");
GC.KeepAlive(timer);
}
}
and the callback method, CheckCalls:
private static void CheckCalls(object objectState)
{
EventLog eventLog1 = new EventLog("MyServiceLog", "DAVIDWIN7", "MyService");
eventLog1.WriteEntry("MyService is polling");
}
Arg--For some reason when you Build->Clean Solution, then Build->Build Solution, Visual Studio does not rebuild your setup project. I believe my code above works fine, but I had tried many different fixes without explicitly right-clicking the setup project and selecting Build.
I thought Clean Solution would force all projects to be rebuilt on next build???

it's got to be an error with the timer thread writing to the event log.
I got it working on my computer but I replaced all the eventlog with Console.writeline because I didn't want to mess with my event log permissions.

Did you check if the account under which the service is running has access to the eventlog?

Please can you go and download this test application which mirrors exactly the scenario you are talking about:
https://docs.google.com/leaf?id=0Bw_NnV9fhgmgMThjNDgzOTgtODNiOC00NDE1LWEyMTYtNzVhOTMyNzlmZjZk&hl=en&authkey=CMuupNkC
I've just created this. It's a service that effectively uses the same code as you. The only difference is that I have used the toolbox to drag and drop an eventlog on to the service designer - setting the log to 'Application' and the source to 'Service1'.
Open a VS command prompt at the project folder, go to bin\debug and run installutil windowsservice1.exe - specifying some credentials (so you're installing the dev service directly from your bin output folder).
Start the service and monitor the application log - it will write every ten seconds as you expect to see from your code.
Assuming this works on your machine(tm) like it does on my machine(tm) then I would suggest that the problem is the event logging itself, or, horror of horrors - your service isn't running from your build output folder (most of the devs in my team insist on running their dev services from a different folder and then swear when they forget to actually update the binaries when they start debugging it!).
As I suggested in my comment, you really need to be able to attach the debugger to this and breakpoint the callback to verify that it's not getting fired. I never rely on the eventlog for diagnostics messages simply because the log might be full, or permissions might prevent you etc etc - it might be a windows platform component, but it's not as reliable as I would like.
The debugger, however, rarely lies (unless the deployed binaries are out of date ;) ). Compile a debug build of your project and make sure it's the one that is installed in the services list, start it up and then attach directly to the service exe (there's no point trying to attach to [service].vshost.exe - VS cannot auto-attach or host windows services as the only way they can run is via svchost.exe shelling them).
Hope this helps.