Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.
We don’t allow questions seeking recommendations for books, tools, software libraries, and more. You can edit the question so it can be answered with facts and citations.
Closed 1 year ago.
Improve this question
all, I'm thinking of porting my application from VB.net to the C# based MONO project, so it can run on both Windows and Mac. However, I am in need of a Mac-friendly alternative to WPF. It has to have very similar functionality. QML (by QT) is not a viable option, as it costs far too much money for us.
There is also https://github.com/AvaloniaUI/Avalonia a multi-platform .NET UI framework inspired by WPF
Miguel de Icaza recommends MonoMac as a substitute to WPF for Mac as stated here. As he explains there is no plan to implement WPF in mono.
MonoMac is a work-in-progress. Some parts of the Cocoa APIs are not wrapped yet. You should start with the samples to get an idea of what is possible.
You will have to build two different UI on top of a common engine, but that's generally a good separation of concerns.
There is also a possible common code base for UI with GTK#.
Depending on your application's functionality, you could potentially port your application to Silverlight/Moonlight. Silverlight is supported on the MAC, but you'll need Moonlight for Linux. Of course, if you're doing a lot of work with the client machine's file system or what not, this is not an option.
tho I have accepted an answer a while back, I want to post what I am doing currently if anyone views this question.
I am currently using Python with PyGTK for the GUI, and GStreamer for the video. This is producing results almost identical to WPF (except some hardcoded animations). Furthermore, it runs on Windows, Mac, and Linux.
EDIT: GStreamer did not pan out for my purposes. While it works well for the most part, I could not layer transparent .png images over the video. I have switched finally to Adobe Flash (Adobe AIR).
EDIT 2: For anyone who comes across this later, when the future of SWF fell into question, my company started building our own animation system in C++, using some components of Gtk+/gtkmm and Cairo. Ultimately, that falls under the advice of the other answer...separate GUI from platform.
https://www.noesisengine.com/
Is another alternative to xaml/wpf that is also for video game engines. It currently has a Indie/Free tier up to 100k in revenue, and is cross platform.
Related
Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.
We don’t allow questions seeking recommendations for books, tools, software libraries, and more. You can edit the question so it can be answered with facts and citations.
Closed 4 years ago.
Improve this question
I have a C# WPF program that I’ve been working on for a while now and I need to move to Linux. I know that Moonlight is dead and Monodevelop has no future plans of implementing WPF functionality. Does anyone have any advice for the most painless way to rebuild my program in Linux? It’s a DnD character generator that uses a GUI with tab controls to separate the different parts. I only know C# but I’d learn another language if it was the best way.
The .NET Framework was planned for Platform independant, but that never realised. It grew too big to fully port.
.NET Core does not have that issue. It was cut down compared to the .NET Framework. It supports neither WPF nor Windows Forms, but it does support something similar: UWP. Wich is basically "WPF with App environment added". Since your programm propably needs no extensvie rights, UWP might be the way to go.
Edit: With .NET Core 3.0, thie Windows Forms Support will be added again. .NET Framework targetting WinForms Programms will need a conversion, but if you start from scratch it should just work.
Otherwise the common GUI to do cross platform anything is Xamarian. But Xamarian Apps are usually designed from the get go as such.
Closed. This question is opinion-based. It is not currently accepting answers.
Want to improve this question? Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post.
Closed 8 years ago.
Improve this question
I'm currently having some analysis paralysis in deciding which is better for me between C++ using the Qt framework, or C# using the .NET framework for developing a small to medium sided project I currently designing.
I have a little experience in both languages, slightly more in C++ however would probably still be considered a novice.
All the information I have read has been relativity outdated (being at least a couple of years old) and was wondering if there have been any updates that would swing the advantage one way or another, or if it really is just a matter of preference.
QT seems to support my particular requirements needs slightly better however the additional difficulty of working in C++ may offset taking me back to square 1.
My requirements are fairly simple, I will need rich text support, database connections, the ability to export to various file types and have a fairly dynamic GUI.
Anyone have any personally experiences or recommendations they wish to share?
I recommend to use Qt because:
It's cross-platform and covers wide range of operating systems (including mobile)
Writing in C++ gives you the opportunity to use libraries
like the STL, Boost, etc;
Using C++ gives you the benefit of running your app at high speed
It is opensource and has a fast speed in getting better
It has the a nice GUI designer and a very capable IDE (Qt Creator)
The API design is excellent and easy to use
It has a great documentation which is easy to read
It has the Qt translation system which enables you to have a multilingual app
The GUI layout system where the widgets resize themselves according to a layout makes everything much easier
The QML gives you the power to create fantastic GUI with great graphics and animations
It has great support for networking and connectivity(socket, SSL, www, IPC, ...)
It has QTestLib for testing the code
It has many language binding if you don't want to use C++
You can learn Qt easily if you know C++
All requirements you have given are completely feasible and easy to do in Qt
It doesn't require any VM for deployment but .NET needs that.
Your application will be cross platform
Creating custom UI is very much possible in Qt. You can create almost any kind of UI in Qt.
Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.
We don’t allow questions seeking recommendations for books, tools, software libraries, and more. You can edit the question so it can be answered with facts and citations.
Closed 7 years ago.
Improve this question
I was recently sent this link to Statsd which would be an interesting tool for us to monitor various aspects of our product, but it would be a hard-sell for us because of the PHP and non-Windows toolset. (This question asks about installing this on Windows, without an answer...)
Can anyone recommend Windows / .Net toolsets that might provide similar low-overhead monitoring of systems? Within reason, paying for a toolset should not be a problem.
I did find this microsoft page that looks quite interesting, but let's be honest, it does not have as many cool graphs that show the kind of thing that would be nice to have as an end-result :)
Your experiences and thoughts on direction would be appreciated: I think our ultimate goal would be 'wall-boards' e.g. large screens cycling through several key graphs or views so the whole team could understand and monitor some key metrics of the products we are supporting. Our client uses SQL Server Reporting Services for this, but their reports seem to be mostly statistical and very little graphical.
I've ported Graphite to Windows. It was pretty easy to do this. I've issued a pull request to the main project. I hope it will get merged. Until then, you find the fork under:
https://github.com/stephanstapel/carbon
Graphite installation requires some additional steps I published here:
http://www.s2-industries.com/wordpress/2012/12/running-graphite-on-windows/
Why not run Graphite in a Linux VM on top of a windows server? You get the full support of the graphite community, while being completely hosted on windows.
If you were wanting to replicate statsd, I would create a Windows service listening via UDP on a specific port. With a fairly open database schema, you could mimic its low-friction fluidity. That would take care of statsd and Carbon, the data collector piece of Graphite. You would then need to write a management tool that analyzes and presents the data in place of Graphite.
I would, for this reason, encourage you to just take the Linux route. Otherwise, you'd be fighting every battle the developers of those tools fought all over again.
Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.
We don’t allow questions seeking recommendations for books, tools, software libraries, and more. You can edit the question so it can be answered with facts and citations.
Closed 7 years ago.
Improve this question
Was just wondering if there were any cross platform development platforms which would run great for corporate type apps on various mobile devices.
Would be ideal if the language was C# but feel free to suggest others.
If you're happy to re-use business logic and write device specific user interfaces (more work, but better user experience on each device) you could consider the various Mono frameworks.
Writing the core business logic as a class library, then writing specific user interfaces using MonoTouch, MonoDroid and Windows using .NET Framework you'll have a cross platform application (albeit with individual UIs) in C#.
have you checked out Titanium at http://www.appcelerator.com
And then there is the PhoneGap at http://www.phonegap.com/
Worth noting that you'd be writing once for the PLATFORM, but being certain that your app works on the DEVICES is a different kettle of fish due to the variety of handset providers, their customized platform implementations and the hardware specific to the device.
Check out these related questions... otherwise know as duplicates....
Developing cross platform mobile application
Are there any huge differences between objective-c and Java, or iPhone and Android?
What work has been done on cross-platform mobile development?
Titanium Mobile is a popular choice these days.
I strongly doubt that you'll find a C# option* that's cross-platform since C# is tied to the Microsoft stack.
You could also just write a mobile-centric webapp with jQuery Mobile or similar.
*For mobile. For desktop, there's Mono (whose site appears to be down right now).
well if you've got a mac, your best bet would be to go for phonegap which supports a wide range of platforms,
if not, you could go for titanium
Although there are many platforms that provide you the facility to write once and run on multiple platform but from my point of view its not a great idea for simple reason of performance just think of below example
A C code is far faster than a java code because java provides you the virtual machine to run that code and java is far more easier to write than that of C. The idea is the more you stick close to native API the more you will get performance.
So considering the above example just think what will be the performance of such application that is supported on so many platforms
Note: I have not worked on any of such platforms so I might be wrong but this just a simple conception that fits to all
If you are used to working with Visual Studio, you can try Teleric's http://www.icenium.com/ . Icenium does not support Windows Mobile 6 though
Closed. This question is opinion-based. It is not currently accepting answers.
Want to improve this question? Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post.
Closed 5 years ago.
Improve this question
I want to write simple application with some 3D objects for Windows OS.
The application is very simple, like a gallery where we can move and see some pictures. When users go to the some picture and click on it a window will open and show picture with some information.
Which is the best framework for this task WPF, XNA, or something else? Application will be written in C#.
I can not say which is best, but I have done a while ago some things with the WPF 3D API and I liked it.
It was IMO very simple to use and the rendering seemed to be relatively fast. A really nice thing I found, was that it has an object-model that contains high-level-events such as mouse-down and click. Therefore you don't have to do much math. However, maybe provide also other APIs such high-level services, I don't know.
I would not try to create an action-game with it, but for a small app as you have described, I think it is worth a try.
Unity has been used for similar stuff. It can work on browsers (via a plug-in) or as a program, has a lot of documentation and most of the work involved in creating a 3D environment and interface is already done. Code can be written in Mono (open source C# implementation), JavaScript or a Boo, a modified Python scripting language.
It works in Windows, MacOS, iPhone, iPad and Android. And it is free in the standard version, or really cheap.
XNA is a little lower level, so it will require more work to get things started. It supports Windows, WP7 and Xbox 360.
See this discussion : WPF VS XNA