I have some code written in Python which can not be transferred to a .NET language. I need to call one of these functions from my .NET WinForms application.
Now, I do it by starting the Python script as a separate process and pass parameters to it as command line arguments. It works, but I don't really like this solution. I'd like to improve it to a better one.
Is there any better way to call a function of a .py script from a .NET application? What is the best way to do it?
Note: IronPython is NOT an option for this Python script
This might be a lot more work than launching the Python process, but here's an alternate solution.
You can embed Python into another program. The API is for C and Interop from .NET will probably be a major pain. If you're into a bit of a safer way to handle the native Python API, you can look into Boost.Python, which, among its less advertised features, has support for embedding.
With these tools, you can write a C++ managed DLL that uses Boost.Python to load the Python interpreter and execute any Python script. Thus, you can execute any Python code directly in the hosting process, eliminating the use of an external process and any form of IPC.
Edit: AFAIK, all you have to add to your installation procedure is the deployment of the Python DLL and Boost.Python DLL.
Besides the COM option, you could make your Python script instantiate a xmlrpc server -
it is quite transparent and you never have to deal with "xml" on your own code.
Then, on .net side, you simply connect to your python app via xmlrpc - if there is no suitable way to do that in C#, just write a client function in IronPython.
The SimpleXMLRPCServer example on Python documentation is enough for that:
http://docs.python.org/library/simplexmlrpcserver.html
I think you need to re-evaluate Carlos' answer.
See the section Implementing COM Objects with Python in Mark Hammond's book Python Programming on Win32.
You should be able to create a COM object, then have .Net interact with it.
From the book the following will create a COM server with a single method.
# SimpleCOMServer.py - A sample COM server - almost as small as they come!
#
# We expose a single method in a Python COM object.
class PythonUtilities:
_public_methods_ = [ 'SplitString' ]
_reg_progid_ = "PythonDemos.Utilities"
# NEVER copy the following ID
# Use "print pythoncom.CreateGuid()" to make a new one.
_reg_clsid_ = "{41E24E95-D45A-11D2-852C-204C4F4F5020}"
def SplitString(self, val, item=None):
import string
if item != None: item = str(item)
return string.split(str(val), item)
# Add code so that when this script is run by
# Python.exe, it self-registers.
if __name__=='__main__':
print "Registering COM server..."
import win32com.server.register
win32com.server.register.UseCommandLine(PythonUtilities)
The book goes on to say ".. you can do this by executing the code as a normal Python script. The easiest way to do this is to open the source file in PythonWin and use the Run command from the File menu. "
I think you need the ActivePython distribution from Activestate to do it.
See this question Consuming Python COM Server from .NET
It works, but I don't really like this solution, I'd like to improve it to a better one.
No, AFAIK there isn't a better solution, especially if IronPython is a no-no for you. So you could still keep this as a temporary workaround while waiting for the script to be migrated to .NET or until you find that someone already wrote a library on .NET that provides you with similar functionality.
Create a COM .dll from a .py script and use Interop in your .NET code.
Have a look here: http://docs.python.org/faq/windows.html
PythonNet should help with this one. It enables you to call python code from C#.
A cleaner way is to expose the python script via a Flask REST API and consume that from your .NET Application. Don't forget to put proper authentication in place.
Related
I want to create a wrapper for this client for a game but it's in Java. How would I run the .jar file in C#?
Have you looked into IKVM.NET?
What about using Exec to run the appropriate java -jar file.jar command? You might want to add some fancy logic to try and ensure a java is indeed available on the system, but that shouldn't be too hard...
One option is JuggerNET by CodeMesh, which generates .NET wrappers for Java APIs.
The wrapper is called wrapper because it wraps the jar file and starts it using a virtual machine. There are also some wrappers that already contain the VM in the exe file.
You do not need to write such a wrapper by yourself, these are already. One powerful and free wrapper is launch4j.
I have some python code that does a certain task. I need to call this code from C# without converting the python file as an .exe, since the whole application is built on C#.
How can I do this?
If your python code can be executed via IronPython then this is definitely the way to go - it offers the best interop and means that you will be able to use .Net objects in your scripts.
There are many ways to invoke IronPython scripts from C# ranging from compiling the script up as an executable to executing a single script file or event dynamically executing expressions as they are typed in by the user - check the documentation and post another question if you are still haivng problems.
If your script is a CPython script and can't be adapted to work with IronPython then your options are more limited. I believe that some CPython / C# interop exists, but I couldn't find it after a quick Google search. The best thing I can think of would be to just invoke the script directly using python.exe and the Process class.
Have a look at IronPython.
Based on your answer and comments, I believe that the best thing you can do is to embed IronPython in your application. As always, there is a relevant SO question about this. As Kragen said, it is important not to rely on a CPython module.
Process.Start is what you're after. It allows you to call another program, passing it arguments.
I would like to write simple scripts in C#. Stuff I would normally use .bat or 4NT .btm files for. Copying files, parsing text, asking user input, and so on. Fairly simple but doing this stuff right in a batch file is really hard (no exceptions for example).
I'm familiar with command line "scripting" wrappers like AxScript so that gets me part of the way there. What I'm missing is the easy file-manipulation framework. I want to be able to do cd(".."), copy(srcFile, destFile) type functionality.
Tools I have tried:
NANT, which we use in our build process. Not a good scripting tool. Insanely verbose XML syntax and to add a simple function you must write an extension assembly. Can't do it inline.
PowerShell. Looks great, but I just haven't been able to switch over to this as my primary shell. Too many differences from 4NT. Whatever I do needs to run from an ordinary command prompt and not require a special shell to run it through. Can PowerShell be used as a script executor?
Perl/Python/Ruby. Really hate learning an entirely new language and framework just to do batch file operations. Haven't been able to dedicate the time I need to do this. Plus, we're a 99% .NET shop for our toolchain and I really want to leverage our existing experience and codebase.
Are there frameworks out there that are trying to solve this problem of "make a batch file in C#" that you have used?
I want the power of C#/.NET with the immediate-mode type functionality of a typical cmd.exe shell language. Am I alone in wanting something like this?
I would try to get over the PowerShell anxiety because it is the shell of the future. All of the software coming out of Microsoft is using it as their management interface and especially version 2.0 is ridiculously useful.
I'm a C# developer most of the time but PowerShell has solved that whole "WindowsApplication42" problem of temp projects just piling up. PowerShell gives you full access to the .NET framework in a command line shell so even if you don't know how to do something in PowerShell, you most likely know how to do it in .NET.
IronPython and IronRuby do let you leverage all of your .NET "experience and codebase" (they don't answer your objection to learning new languages, however).
If you have any bash nerds, you can always try cygwin.
Also remember that Python was originally intended as a "glue" langauge. If you used the aforementioned IronPython, it's pretty easy to tie together pre-written C# classes.
If you are bind to MS, PowerShell is surely the way to go. But I don't like it much.
I personally use MSBuild script more, and would like to see Mono C# Shell one day comes to Windows.
I think CS-Script might be the ideal solution for you.
I want to run javascript/Python/Ruby inside my application.
I have an application that creates process automatically based on user's definition. The process is generated in C#. I want to enable advanced users to inject script in predefined locations. Those scripts should be run from the C# process.
For example, the created process will have some activities and in the middle the script should be run and then the process continues as before.
Is there a mechanism to run those scripts from C#?
Basically, you have two problems: how to define point of injections in your generated code, and how to run python / ruby / whatev scripts from there.
Depending on how you generate the process, one possible solution would be to add a function to each possible point of injection. The function would check, whether the user has associated any scripts with given points, and if so, runs the script by invoking IronPython / IronRuby (with optionally given parameters).
Disadvantages include: limited accessibility from the scripts to the created process (basically, only variables passed as parameters could be accessed); as well as implementation limits (IronPython's current version omits several basic system functions).
Look into IronPython and IronRuby -- these will allow you to easily interoperate with C#.
You can compile C# code from within a C# application using the CSharpCodeProvider class.
If the compile succeeds you can run the resulting assembly as returned via the CompiledAssembly property of the CompilerResults class.
Awesome C# scripting language - Script.Net
.NET has a scripting language including runtime engine in PowerShell which can be embedded in any .NET application.
You can compile C# code "on the fly" into an in-memory assembly. I think this is possible with IronPython and IronRuby as well. Look at the CodeDomProvider.CreateProvider method.
If you need to run scripts a lot, or if your process runs for a long time, you might want to load these assemblies into another AppDomain. And unload the AppDomain after you're done with the script. Otherwise you are unable to remove them from memory. This has some consequenses on the other classes in your project, because you have to marshall all calls.
Have you thought about Visual Studio for Applications? I haven't heard much about it since .NET 1.1, but it might be worth a look.
http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms974548.aspx
I've done exactly this just recently - allowed run-time addition of C# scripting.
It's not hard at all, and this article:
http://www.divil.co.uk/net/articles/plugins/scripting.asp
is a very useful summary of the details.
One of Microsoft's solutions to JavaScript in C# is ClearScript,
which uses V8, Chrom browser's JavaScript engine. Check its short FAQtorial for code samples.
It has excellent two-way integration - iterator/enumerator, output parameters, optional parameters, parameter arrays, delegate, task/promise/async/await, bigint, and more.
Apart from that, I think the most distinguishing feature is that it does not depend on Rosyln or Dynamic Language Runtime. This can be good or bad - good because there may be a lot less dependencies (depending on your project's target), bad because you need to bundle the native, platform-dependent V8 dll.
If that is ok, you get to enjoy cutting edge JavaScript / ECMAScript. Everything you get on Chrome, or 98% ES6 as of 2022 Feb, plus several extensions. Speed is as fast as Chrome, obviously, so you get the best of both Google and Microsoft.
Does anyone have a good solution for integrating some C# code into a java application?
The code is small, so I could re-write in java, but I would rather reuse the code if possible. Don't repeat yourself, etc.
Also, I know I can expose the C# as a web service or whatever, but it has some security/encryption stuff in there, so I would rather keep it tightly integrated if possible.
Edit: It's going to be on a server-based app, so "downloading" another runtime is irrelevant.
You would use the Java Native Interface to call your C# code compiled into a DLL.
If its a small amount of C#, it would be much easier to port it to Java. If its a lot, this might be a good way to do it.
Here is a highlevel overview of it:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_Native_Interface
Your other option would be to create a COM assembly from the C# code and use J-Interop to invoke it.
http://sourceforge.net/projects/j-interop/
I am author of jni4net, open source intraprocess bridge between JVM and CLR. It's build on top of JNI and PInvoke. No C/C++ code needed. I hope it will help you.
If it's short, I think you're better off re-writing the code in java. Downloading one 50Mb runtime is bad enough.
There is an IL to Java Bytecode compiler GrassHopper which may be of use to you. I've never tried it though.
I'd look at rewriting your code in Java though
EDIT: Note that Grasshopper seems to be no longer available.
We used JNBridge for this, and it worked great. It handles Java->.NET and vice versa, all in-proc.
If you do not want to rewrite hadle it as an Inter-process communication and choose one of following:
Named pipes
Sockets
SOAP
I would rewrite it if it's not too much trouble.
The web service would work, but it seems like that would be a lot of overhead just to reuse a little code.
http://www.infoq.com/articles/in-process-java-net-integration suggests running CLR and JVM in the same process space and passing calls back and forth. It sounds very efficient. I'm going to give it a try and integrate it into Jace if it works well.
If it is a piece of code that is exposable as a command line utility, I just make the other host language use a system call to execute the utility.
If your C# app needs to call Java, compile a special Java main that takes appropriate command line args and returns text output.
It the oldest, simplest method.
You can call your c# classes (compiled in a dll) via a bridging library, various libraries are available, every one with his characteristics. JNBridge generate proxy classes that you can call to manage the code in java classes. JCOBridge let you load your c# classes and use it from java using the invoke mechanism, also javonet let you import java classes and call java code using the invoke mechanism. All the explored solutions are commercial solutions that let you call java code from .NET and vice-versa with graphical user interface integration and other amenities.
Links:
jnbridge java-.NET bridge Developer and Deployment license schema with 30 day free trial
jcobridge java-.NET bridge Developer and Deployment license schema with unlimited Trial
javonet java-.NET bridge Research and Professional license schema with 30-day unlimited Trial after sign-up