How can a static property reference a nonstatic method?
Example:
public static int UserID
{
get
{
return GetUserID();
}
}
private int GetUserID()
{
return 1;
}
When I try to compile this, I get the error: "An object reference is required for he non-static field, method or property "GetUserID()"
This doesn't work.
When you define a static property (or static method), you're defining a property that works on the class type, not on an instance of the class.
Instance properties and methods, on the other hand, work upon a specific, constructed, instance of a class. In order to use them, you need to have a reference to that specific instance. (The other way around, however, is fine.)
As an example, think of Fruit, and an "Apple" class. Say the apple class has an instance property that is how ripe the Apple is at this point in time.
You wouldn't as "Apple" to describe how ripe it is, but rather a specific "Apple" (instance). On the other hand, you could have an instance of an apple, and ask it whether it contains seeds (which might be defined on the Apple class itself (static)).
You'll just have to create a new instance:
public static int UserID
{
get
{
return new MyClass().GetUserID()
}
}
Well, you don't have to create a new instance every time UserId is called -- you can have a static field containing an instance of MyClass instead (which of course would be an approach toward implementing the Singleton pattern).
Although you can read that your static property is calling a method that could be made static, the other method isn't static. Thus, you must call the method on an instance.
You need somehow to get an instance. Without an instance, it's impossible to call an instance method.
For your case, are you sure that you need GetUserID() to be an instance method? It returns anyway the same value. Or, if your code is just dummy, and you require more logic in GetUserID(), maybe you can tell us what you intend to do?
An easy way to think about it is the following: a non-static method (or property, because properties are just wrapped-up methods) receives, as a first hidden parameter, a reference to the instance on which they operate (the "this" instance within the called method). A static method has no such instance, hence nothing to give as first hidden parameter to the non-static method.
Simply it can't.
If you need to call a static method to invoke an instance method, probably you want a Singleton
Try look at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singleton_pattern
Example:
public sealed class Singleton
{
private static readonly Singleton _instance = new Singleton();
private Singleton() { }
public static Singleton Instance
{
get
{
return _instance;
}
}
public static int UserID
{
get
{
return _instance.GetUserID();
}
}
private int GetUserID()
{
return 1;
}
}
Related
I just noticed that i am able to pass private object to another class by a reference
I would guess this should not be possible but it works fine
Here an example
private static StreamWriter swYandexErrors; // in classA
csLogger.logAnyError(ref swYandexErrors, $"msg", E); // in classA
// in class csLogger
public static void logAnyError(ref StreamWriter swError,
string srError, Exception E = null)
{
lock (swError)
{
swError.WriteLine("");
swError.Flush();
}
}
private means just private for that variable, not for the actual instance which is referenced by that variable. So the reference swYandexErrors which is private in your class is of course not visible to the other one. However as you´re passing the instance by reference you can of course access the instance within your first class.
To be more clear the following does not work in class csLogger and causes a compiler-error as you can´t access swYandexErrors within csLogger:
public static void DoSomething()
{
ClassA.swYandexErrors.Read();
}
As an aside: you don´t even need the ref-keyword in your method, as you don´t re-assign the passed StreamWriter. All you´re doing is to call members on the passed instance.
If I try to declare static and non-static methods with the same parameters compiler returns an error: type 'Test' already defines a member called 'Load' with the same parameter types.
class Test
{
int i = 0;
public int I
{
get { return i; }
set { i = value; }
}
public bool Load(int newValue)
{
i = newValue;
return true;
}
public static Test Load(int newValue)
{
Test t = new Test();
t.I = newValue;
return t;
}
As far as I know these two methods can not be mixed, non static method is called on object whereas static method is called on class, so why does compiler not allow something like this and is there a way to do something similar?
If your Test class had a method like this:
public void CallLoad()
{
Load(5);
}
the compiler would not know which Load() to use. Calling a static method without the class name is entirely allowed for class members.
As for how to do something similar, I guess your best bet is to give the methods similar but different names, such as renaming the static method to LoadTest() or LoadItem().
Inside the class itself, you call both instance methods and static methods without an instance or the class name, thus making the two undistinguishable if the names and parameters are the same:
class Test
{
public void Foo()
{
Load(0); // Are you trying to call the static or the instance method?
}
// ...
}
The signature of a method is the combination of name and parameters (number and types).
In your case, your 2 methods have the same identical signature. The fact that one is static and other one is not makes no difference in accepting them as valid methods for the class.
I don't think so. if a non static method in this class calls Load(intValue). which method will be called?
Both methods have the same name, defined in the same class (scope) and with the same signature. C# does not allow this.
The problem is not related with writing this or the classname. C# specs allow you to call static methods using object instances:
AClass objectA = new AClass();
objectA.CallStaticMethod();
This code is valid so the compiler never has a way to know if you're calling a static or an instance method.
In C# a method cannot be overloaded by return type. It must at least have a different set of parameters, regardless if the method is static or not.
Can i access a method from a instance of the class? Example:
class myClass
{
private static int n = 0;
public static myClass()
{ n = 5;}
public static void Afis()
{
Console.WriteLine(n);
}
}
and in the void Main:
static void Main()
{
myClass m = new myClass();
m.Afis();
}
This gives me: cannon be accessed with an instance referece. Is it because i declared the function static? If that is so when should I use static and when not because in c++ if i declare something with static it just initialize once. Is that the case with c#?
You need to use the class name rather than your variable name to access the static method.
myClass.Afis();
I've attached a link to the Static Classes and Static Class Members programming guide as you've asked when you should use them and not use them.
A little exert from the programming guide:
A static class can be used as a convenient container for sets of
methods that just operate on input parameters and do not have to get
or set any internal instance fields. For example, in the .NET
Framework Class Library, the static System.Math class contains methods
that perform mathematical operations, without any requirement to store
or retrieve data that is unique to a particular instance of the Math
class.
Static methods are called through the class itself, not an instance of the class.
static void Main()
{
myClass m = new myClass();
myClass.Afis();
}
That's right - it's a static function and therefore is called like:
myClass.Afis();
Is it because i declared the function static?
Exactly.
If that is so when should I use static
Guess what - from the error: when you do not need to access instance variables.
because in c++ if i declare something with static it just initialize once. Is that the case with
c#?
If you mean a static constructor - yes.
Basically what you have there is not a "class", but a static class that can not be instantiated at all.
Static method is method who connect to the class ad not to instance.
You use this if you want that every instance can use the same method.
For example if I want to count the instances of class I use static property.
To access static methods and properties you have to use the name of the class and not the name of instance.
Yes - as you suspect - you cannot access an static method via an instance of the object, only via the type itself.
In other words:
myClass.Afis();
Naturally - the converse is also true; you cannot access an instance method via the type either.
You can find out more about when to, and no to, use static in other questions such as this one, but I would say that static limits certain desirable things like testability and polymorphism (to name just a couple), and so shouldn't be your "default position".
You marked your method as static. Thus you have to access it via the type.
Static methods are used when the method refers to the type and does not use instance information. String.IsNullOrEmpty(string s) is such a static method. It belongs to the string class but does not need an instance environment. Whereas the ToString() method that every object inherits from object needs an instance context to define what to express as a string.
public static void callit(ref int var)
{
var++;
}
public static void main(Object sender, EventArgs e)
{
int num=6;
callit(ref num);
Console.WriteLine(num);
}
But if here method callit() would not be a static then I had to make object of class then call it.
That's correct. Non-static methods need to be called on an instance of an object. Even if the method doesn't actually use any other members of the object, the compiler still enforces the rule that instance methods require instances. Static methods, on the other hand, do not need to be called on an instance. That's what makes them static.
Exactly because that's the whole point of static methods.
Instance methods require to know which instance of the class you call the method on.
instance.Method();
and they can then reference instance variables in the class.
Static methods, on the other hand, don't require an instance, but can't access instance variables.
class.StaticMethod();
An example of this would be:
public class ExampleClass
{
public int InstanceNumber { get; set; }
public static void HelpMe()
{
Console.WriteLine("I'm helping you.");
// can't access InstanceNumber, which is an instance member, from a static method.
}
public int Work()
{
return InstanceNumber * 10;
}
}
You could create an instance of this class to call the Work() method on that particular instance
var example = new ExampleClass();
example.InstanceNumber = 100;
example.Work();
The static keyword though, means that you don't need an instance reference to call the HelpMe() method, since it's bound to the class, and not to a particular instance of the class
ExampleClass.HelpMe();
I think MSDN explains it very well
Static classes and class members are used to create data and functions that can be accessed without creating an instance of the class. Static class members can be used to separate data and behavior that is independent of any object identity: the data and functions do not change regardless of what happens to the object. Static classes can be used when there is no data or behavior in the class that depends on object identity.
You can find more details about this topic here
This is simply a matter of C# syntax, if I understand your question correctly. There is no ambiguity in using callit(ref num); in your example. It is known exactly what method to call, since it is a static method and there is no object attached. On the other hand, if callit was not static, the compiler would not know the object on which to call the method, since you are calling it from a static method (which has no object). So, you would need to create a new object and call the method on that object.
Of course, if neither method was static, the method call would operate on itself, and again, the object would be known so there is no problem.
Because static methods are associated with the class itself, not with a specific object instance.
Static functions work on classes.
Member functions work on instances.
And yes, you can only call a member function of an object (instance). No instance, no member.
Static methods are called on the type (or class), whereas non-static methods are called on the instance of a type i.e. object of a class.
You cannot call non-static methods or non-static variables in a static method, as there can be multiple objects (i.e. instances of the same type).
Static functions access class variables that are just as accessible by any other static functions AND instance functions. Meaning if you have a class variable called static int count, in static method static increaseCount() { count++; } increases the variable count by 1, and in static method static decreaseCount() { count--; } decreases the variable count by 1.
Therefore, both a static function and an instance function may access a static variable, but a static function MAY NOT access an instance variable.
Static functions are also called class functions.
Non static functions are also called instance functions.
Static method are independent of instance, suppose there is man class in that there is eat method which is non static and there is sleep method which is static then when you create different instance of man lets say man m1, m2. m1 and m2 share same sleep methods but different eat method. In java all static variables are stored in heap memory which is shared all object instances suppose at runtime if static variable changes then it will share on all instances of the object in our case.m1 and m2. But if you change non-static varible it will for only that object instance
m1.anStaticvariable = 1; // changes value of m2.anStaticvariable also
But
m1.nonStaticvariable = 1; //wont change m2.nonStaticvariable
Hope this helps you
I have a static function in a class.
whenever I try to use non static data member, I get following compile error.
An object reference is required for the nonstatic field, method, or property member
Why is it behaving like that?
A non-static member belongs to an instance. It's meaningless without somehow resolving which instance of a class you are talking about. In a static context, you don't have an instance, that's why you can't access a non-static member without explicitly mentioning an object reference.
In fact, you can access a non-static member in a static context by specifying the object reference explicitly:
class HelloWorld {
int i;
public HelloWorld(int i) { this.i = i; }
public static void Print(HelloWorld instance) {
Console.WriteLine(instance.i);
}
}
var test = new HelloWorld(1);
var test2 = new HelloWorld(2);
HelloWorld.Print(test);
Without explicitly referring to the instance in the Print method, how would it know it should print 1 and not 2?
Instance methods rely on state of that particular instance in order to run.
Let's say you had this class which has the scenario you describe:
class Person
{
static PrintName()
{
// Not legal, but let's say it is for now.
Console.WriteLine(Name);
}
private Name { get; set; }
}
Hopefully, the problem is apparent now. Because Name is an instance member, you need an actual instance of the class, since Name can be different across different instances.
Because of this, the static method, which is not attached to an instance, doesn't know which instance to use. You have to be explicit in specifying which one.
A static method cannot directly access any non-static member variables of a class.
After all : a static method can be called without an instance of the class even being in existance. How do you want to access a member variable on a non-existing instance??
(of course, as Mehrdad pointed out: you could pass an instance of your class to a static method and access everything on that instance - but that's not what you're talking about, right?)
Static functions can only use static members, and call static functions.
As mentioned, a static function can operate on a class instance, but not from within a class instance (for lack of a more descriptive word). For example:
class MyClass
{
public int x;
public static int y;
public static void TestFunc()
{
x = 5; // Invalid, because there is no 'this' context here
y = 5; // Valid, because y is not associated with an object instance
}
public static void TestFunc2(MyClass instance)
{
instance.x = 5; // Valid
instance.y = 5; // Invalid in C# (valid w/ a warning in VB.NET)
}
}
The definition of a "non static data member" would be an "instance data member". In other words non static members belong to a created instance of your class.
A static method does not run in the context of any specific instance of the class. Hence when you ask such a method to use a non static member it will have no idea which of the 0 or more instances of the class it should try to get the data from.
You can't access non-static data from a static function. This is because the static function can be called irrespective of whether there are any instantiated objects of the class. The non-static data, however, is dependent on a specific object (instantiation) of the class. Since you can't be sure that there are any objects instantiated when calling a static function, it is illogical (and therefore not allowed) to access non-static data from it.
This question has been asked several times on SO in different forms / for different languages:
C#
Java
Python
PHP
Language-independent